patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

In Education, is Connecticut Losing its Competitive Edge?

Connecticut Realtors provide a good barometer of the economy’s health. They know why people move in and move out, the canary in the coal mine so to speak.  National headlines that proclaim our high taxes and bonding downgrades make selling our state more difficult. The one competitive advantage realtors point to has always been the state’s top ranking in Education until recently.

In an effort to regain our competitive edge, 350 education leaders and reformers attended an education workshop which was focused on initiatives to seriously address the widest in the nation achievement gap. Our new Education Commissioner, an education reformer, set the stage by describing six guiding principles.

• Enhanced early education

• Under performing schools intervention

• Expanded access to high quality school models

• Cutting red tape

• Teacher evaluation/tenure

• Restructuring school finance​

Breakout sessions included those on low-performing schools, excellent leaders and teachers and school finance.

Panelists at the forefront of reform proposed:

◦ Increased instructional time, longer school days, longer school year.

◦ Fair funding for all types of schools (including Charters) and money follows the child funding structure

◦ Research based models

◦ Financial incentives for quality teachers

◦ Community involvement, including corporate sponsorship

A successful model of teacher evaluations was highlighted by New Haven School officials.

A major component of their system is an evaluation by the principal, vice principal and others each November, rated on a scale of 1 to 5.  One equals poor and 5 is excellent.  Those rated a one would require peer evaluation, increased support, and an improvement plan.

If there is no progress a termination would result even if they have tenure.

Union leaders stress, that process must be one of continual education and performance growth, rather than a “gotcha” by administrators.

Tenure reform proposed by the Superintendents was also discussed.  Their tenure proposal would be delayed until the fifth year rather than the fourth and renewed every five years. 

The panel agreed that standardized test scores must serve in some capacity in the evaluation process. They also agreed that multiple indicators of student growth must be utilized.  Lack of incentives for excellent teachers was briefly discussed at the close of session.

School Finance has been an issue for decades.

Rhode Island presented their recently enacted money follows the student model. Their formula is based on student need, not district need, and resulted in some towns losing funds since there is no hold harmless provision. Data is updated every year, and the state has used existing dollars to transition to the new formula below:

·Core instruction amount of $8679 per student

·Student success factor (free and reduced lunch)

·State share ratio (mean average of district’s wealth and at risk students)

Connecticut factors in wealth but not the number of low income students.

The 2012 legislative session may also entertain a pilot program involving tuition rates.

One controversial proposal for the state’s regional universities (SCSU, ECSU, WCSU CCSU) would offer in state tuition in certain instances to out of state students. The program’s goal is to incentivize enrollment of more out of state students.

Instate tuition hikes are also on people’s minds. Some believe our tuition costs are one of the highest in the nation and increasing rates as proposed would not be a good idea.

The President cautioned higher education institutions in his state of the union:

So let me put colleges and universities on notice:  If you can’t stop tuition from going up, the funding you get from taxpayers will go down.  Higher education can’t be a luxury -– it is an economic imperative that every family in America should be able to afford.

I concur. Getting a secondary education is shown to be the single most important factor in reducing poverty and growing middle income families.

We can all agree that our youth are our best resource and represent the future of our state.  Only through literacy can one truly participate in our system of government and contribute to our economy.

The General Assembly and the Administration must set aside their differences and focus on education reform- free from the constraints of special interests. Only then can our children reach their full potential and Connecticut can regain our competitive edge.

(Senator Boucher is a ranking member on both The State Education Committee and The State Higher Education Committee)

 

Brian Kesselman

8:46 am on Friday, February 3, 2012

Thank you for your comprehensive overview of the education workshop's contents. While there are many sides to the education debates, there is no question that a quality education is an important factor in Wilton. It affects primarily our students, but also our home prices, tax base, local economy and community at large.

Can you provide some more details on the level of involvement that Wilton had at the conference? And what is the intended follow up or result? For instance, was this a single workshop or one of a series? Are the results a finding, proposed regulations, just informational for attendees? And are the results to be used by the State Education Committees or by the school districts?

I am hopeful that our town and state will continue, with leadership of educators and government, and the involvement of residents (with and without students in the schools), to provide an excellent future for us all. Thank you again for your article and your efforts on our behalf.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Michael Graupner

1:45 pm on Friday, February 3, 2012

If you are "hopeful" for "an excellent future for us all", you had better not put much hope in the "leadership of educators and government". The former are either ivory tower socialists or union tools, while the latter are primarily self-serving liars and revisionists. You would do better by becoming more informed as to whether Wilton is truly delivering a "quality education" to its children or whether our tax money is being wasted outside of the classroom.

Comment_arrow

Brian Kesselman

2:22 pm on Sunday, February 5, 2012

Michael, while I'm often cynical with regard to the political process being an efficient means of managing our schools, I maintain my "hope" that work like that described here is intended to specifically promote quality. And, with topics on the table like "restructuring school finance" and "teacher evaluation/tenure" there is an opportunity for us, as taxpayers, to benefit from the result.

I feel I am reasonably informed whether Wilton is truly delivering a "quality education." Like you, I follow the school's public metrics. Also, I have two children currently enrolled and I am able to compare their results and curriculum with those of our friends' children in other towns and states. Certainly there are some better schools (public and private), but most don't compare favorably to Wilton.

With regard to wasted tax dollars I stronly agree. There is money being spent in some areas that I think should be redirected. Some past examples are apparent in the results of the recent arbitration. Factoring in next year's budget line replenishing funding to the pension, the increase is more reasonable this year than it has been for many.

I don't agree that the "quality education" and "tax money wasted" are mutually exclusive. The more efficient our spending, the better positioned we are for success. But neither guarantees the other.

Thanks for joining the conversation.

ETP

8:57 am on Friday, February 3, 2012

The Town wants to spend a couple of million dollars laying in fiber optic cables connecting Town Hall, The High School and the library to facilitate the transmission of as yet undefined data files. They should stick to the internet and save the money.
That kind of money could be used to purchase electronic text books for an iPAD for every Wilton student several times over. Let's put the priority into the classroom instead of loading up on the "peripheral fluff." Is the PTA involved?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Brian Kesselman

2:25 pm on Sunday, February 5, 2012

Ed, I like your thoughts about the fiber optic expense. While it would be nice to capitalize on the shared funding being offered, in the end it carries a steep investment from the taxpayers without a clear enough benefit. Given the advances in compression and encryption technologies that have occurred and are still being developed, there may be no benefit to a private high speed link over a compressed and encrypted link that traverses the existing infrastructure. Thanks.

Toni Boucher

6:01 pm on Friday, February 3, 2012

The workshop was intended to bring together the experts to formulate proposals that would later bring before the education committee by the Governor’s Office. We will have public hearing on the proposals from the Governor Office as well as any developed by the committee after public input. As a ranking member from the state senate I hope to be fully engaged in the those discussions and final vote. These proposals could affect all districts throughout CT. Your local board of education, however, will have the most impact on Wilton’s education quality.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Amo Probus

7:06 pm on Friday, February 3, 2012

Thank you Toni for your efforts. We know its difficult to change Hartford and so we must start with our town...at the schools and at Town Hall. We just need a break from "state mandates" that become crutches, cripple innovation and discourage local activism. We need open forums to get out the message to all concerned citizens. Some vested leaders are fearful of the challenges to their (at times) heavy handedness. Our problems were long in the making but hopefully we can fix them before its too late.

Comment_arrow

Brian Kesselman

2:29 pm on Sunday, February 5, 2012

Thank you for the clarification on the intended results. I concur that we, as residents, taxpayers, parents and public staff must remain vigilant and participate in Wilton's school support organizations, local Board of Education, Board of Finance and Town Government processes to ensure the best and highest value education.

Leave a comment